Sign In | Create an Account | Welcome, . My Account | Logout | Subscribe | Submit News | All Access E-Edition | Home RSS

No smoking: Bans still an issue

February 28, 2013
By SHELLEY HANSON - For The Times Leader , Times Leader

By April 1, smoking at outdoor venues in Marshall County will be against the law.

Marshall County Board of Health members earlier this month approved the regulation, but not before amending one section. They decided to change some language emphasizing that smoking was prohibited in outdoor venues and at fairs and festivals, but that owners or organizers could still ask the health department for permission to designate an area for smokers.

Before taking the vote, they heard from the public, including Haven Inn of Glen Dale owner Jim Weekley, who said he was in favor of expanding the regulation because it included a provision to ban smoking inside hotels and motels.

Article Photos

Photo/Shelley Hanson
Haven Inn owner Jim Weekley listens to debate about expanding the smoking ban in Marshall County. The board approved prohibiting smoking in public outdoor areas.

''It could actually prevent a structure fire,'' Weekley said of the ban, noting he has a difficult time keeping up with the damage caused by smokers in his rooms.

Elizabeth Fager, representing Grand Vue Park, said the ban expansion could decrease the park's revenue from its cabin rentals and that the park would have difficulty enforcing the measure.

County resident Ruth Cook said she was concerned the board would eventually want to ban smoking in private residences, something one board member assured her would not happen.

''I've had a lot of tragedies in my life. ... I think smoking helps me,'' said Cook, a 50-year smoker.

Representing Mound View Health Care, Heather Blake said she was in favor of the ban, noting her concern is tobacco contamination that can linger even after a cigarette is extinguished.

Board member Don Mason said the objective of prohibiting smoking in outdoor public places is to protect children attending events and ballgames. The health department has received complaints from parents concerned about secondhand smoke during such events, prompting the board to take action, said Administrator Ronda Francis.

She noted that during the comment period, some people called her and said they wished the ban included bars and gambling parlors - two places where smoking still is allowed.

Other outdoor areas the ban impacts include playgrounds, swimming pools, outdoor dining areas and waiting lines and more. And unlike before, there will be penalties for breaking the regulation for those found guilty in court of doing so. The regulation will continue to allow smoking in private residences unless the residence is being used as a child care or adult care facility.

Some residents want to see the ban pushed further, while others believe it currently is too stringent.

Moundsville resident and smoker Aubrey Payne disagrees with the ban's expansion to outdoor venues.

''I think it's very wrong to do that. They always talk about non-smokers' rights, what about smokers' rights?'' she said. ''If there is a child beside me I will move - I'm polite about it. They should tell people not be disrespectful.''

Becky Morgan, a Jacobsburg, Ohio, resident, said she enjoys coming to Moundsville's Riverfront Park for summertime concerts. But she dislikes it when people smoke in the crowd. She agrees with the expansion of the ban and believes having a designated area set aside for smokers is OK.

''It's not likely to affect anyone else. ... I lost my dad to smoking. And my mom - she was allergic to the medicine they gave him,'' Morgan noted.

Bellaire resident Martin Paliah said he enjoys shopping and eating out in Moundsville, but he believes the ban should be expanded to bars and bars that serve food as well.



I am looking for:
News, Blogs & Events Web