Food Truck and village of Shadyside go head to head in court over citation
Trending
ST. CLAIRSVILLE - No judgement has been ruled in the Holey Rollers Donut food truck vs the village of Shadyside trial.
The case stems from a $100 citation owner Jeremy Pasztor received on Oct. 2 for operating without a permit inside of the village.
Pasztor claims he paid the $20 village's outdoor food vendor fee. The next day, he said clerk of courts Betty Snyder contacted him nine times informing him he would be required to park his food truck on private property, since the village doesn’t allow any food trucks to operate on village property.
Conversely, Snyder claims the conversation, which occurred on Sept. 29, got heated with Pasztor screaming and cursing at her.
The following day of the call, Mayor Mike Meintel called Pasztor to inform him council would be updating the rules on food trucks during the next meeting, where outdoor food vendor permits must be applied for two to three days ahead of time. However, no action was taken during the following meeting.
During the next meeting, which occurred on Oct. 12, Pasztor and village officials clashed over the incident.
Pasztor spoke during the meeting's open public forum and expressed his disappointment with the village and got into a heated exchange with Meintel.
The case would typically be handled in the village's Mayor's court, but due to a conflict of interest, Meintel asked the case to be handed over to Belmont County Eastern Division Court.
On Thursday afternoon, Pasztor -- representing himself -- and Shadyside law director Kelly Kotur went head to head in the courtroom.
Kotur called upon three witnesses: village office assistant Maren Lucey, Snyder, and Meintel while Pasztor called no witnesses.
Kotur asked Lucey if she heard the Sept. 29 phone call between Snyder and Pasztor, which she said yes.
She said she recalls hearing Pasztor screaming, asking why she was calling him at 8 a.m.
"I did hear Betty’s side of it. She was very apologetic, she was apologizing. She was very understanding. All she had even mentioned was that she wasn’t trying to call to bother anybody," Lucey said. "She was just trying to save the trouble since there had been a prior issue with that specific food truck a couple months back. I don’t have that exact date, but apparently this specific food truck had come into town without a permit, and then the village did end up just letting that slide."
On Aug. 7, Pasztor parked his food truck in front of a local business in the village to celebrate the business' anniversary. The village does not allow any food trucks to operate inside of its loop besides large community events, but Meintel decided to make an exception.
Lucey said she heard Pasztor yelling on the phone, saying “I need to hear you say you understand me. I want to hear you say you understand me. Do you think I’m stupid?”
Kotur then called Snyder to the stand.
Snyder became emotional and expressed she had never had an interaction quite like the one with Pasztor before in her five years working for the village.
"I was very shaken. I began crying, and I was just very shaken over the conversation. It was a different level, it was like a drill sergeant screaming into the phone," Snyder said.
Kotur then asked Snyder if she feared for her safety during the call.
"I did fear for my safety with the tone of voice and the words he was saying, because he was cursing at me, and he kept just saying repeatedly, even when I was repeating it to him, I want to hear you say you understand me."
Kotur then called her last witness, Meintel.
Meintel said after he became aware of the conversation between Snyder and Pasztor, he asked for Pasztor's phone number because he believes there are two sides to each story.
Meintel called Pasztor on Sept. 30 and said he began the conversation making small talk when Pasztor told him to cut to the chase and tell him why he was calling him.
"I said, 'Listen, that’s no way to talk to me. You more or less validated what Miss Snyder told me," Meintel said. "And at that time, per the Ohio Revised Code, Section 730 3.24, the mayor is the chief conservator of peace in the village, and I’m responsible for keeping the peace and protecting the people of that village and property. And at that time, I made a determination that I was revoking his permit. I told him that his permit was revoked, and that he could collect the money that he paid for the permit."
He added he made the decision based on safety concerns for his staff members.
"That’s no way to talk to women in my eyes, and I would make the same decision if I had to do it all over again," Meintel said.
Following Meintel's testimony, Pasztor took the stand.
He said the village never told him he wasn’t allowed to park on private property in August.
Pasztor added once the private property requirement was known to him, he asked Snyder what he would need to do to follow the village's rules.
He said he was told to just pay the $20 vendor's fee to receive his permit, which he did pay.
Pasztor then spoke about the Sept. 29 phone call. He claims he did not curse at Snyder or yell, but did agree that he does tend to have a loud voice.
He added during the Sept. 30 phone call with Meintel, the mayor told him not to come to his village.
Pasztor said his frustration during the Sept. 29 phone call was because he was confused about how many times the village called him in one day, which he has mentioned previously during the council meeting he was present at.
"I even went to the point where I was like, 'Betty, I understand that you think real high [of] Shadyside, like it’s really high up on your priority list, and you want to protect it from people. But you calling me 10 times, and woke my family and I up isn't protecting Shadyside," Pasztor said.
He maintained he did not threaten Snyder or any village employee.
Pasztor said during the Oct. 2 incident, a police officer gave him the citation despite showing the officer his permit. Nevertheless, Pasztor said it wasn’t enough.
"He said that he would arrest me if I sold the donuts that I already made somebody with a valid permit in their village," Pasztor said.
Judge David Trouten informed both parties he would render a verdict in writing on the matter. He said it would probably be by the end of the day, however no verdict was made yet as of press time.